By AHLP | Updated 25 October 2026
A smart lock can be a good upgrade, but only after two checks. First, your home insurance: many insurers still expect a lock that meets a British Standard such as BS3621, and a smart lock that changes the hardware can affect your cover. Second, certification: choose a model independently tested for both physical and cyber security, such as the BSI Kitemark for smart locks. Get those right and going keyless is genuinely convenient.
We get asked about smart locks more and more, usually by people who are fed up with lost keys, spare keys for the cleaner, or that nagging “did I lock the door?” feeling. Here is our honest view, including the parts the manufacturers skip over.
What a smart lock actually does
A smart lock replaces or works with the lock on your door so you can open it without a traditional key. Depending on the model, that means an entry code, a fob or keycard, a fingerprint, or an app on your phone. Most will auto-lock behind you, let you hand a temporary code to a visitor or tradesperson, and tell you from anywhere whether the door is locked.
The honest pros
- No keys to lose, copy or hide. The spare key under the plant pot is a burglar’s first check. Codes and fobs remove it completely.
- Control from anywhere. Let someone in while you are at work, give the dog walker a code that only works at lunchtimes, then delete it.
- Peace of mind. If you have ever driven back home to check the door, an app that tells you it is locked is worth a lot.
- A record of comings and goings. Useful for busy households, and for anyone with carers or regular visitors.
The honest cons
- Batteries. Every smart lock runs on them. Good models warn you for weeks and keep a low-battery fallback, but they are one more thing to maintain.
- It depends on your phone, wifi or app. If the company behind the app shuts down its servers, some features can die with it.
- Cheap models are the weak link. An uncertified smart lock can be less secure than the ordinary lock it replaced, both physically and online. Which? has found serious security flaws in budget internet-connected locks in past testing.
- Not every door suits one. uPVC and composite doors with multi-point locking need specific models, and some smart locks simply will not fit certain doors.
The insurance question you must ask first
This is the part that catches people out. Most home insurance policies have minimum lock standards, commonly BS3621 for wooden doors and TS007 3-star or SS312 Diamond cylinders for uPVC and composite doors. Some smart locks meet no British Standard at all, and fitting one can leave you technically uninsured if the worst happens.
Before you buy anything, read your policy wording or ring your insurer and ask exactly what they require for your final exit door. Our guide to whether your locks meet your home insurance requirements walks through the standards in plain English. Some people keep the rated lock their insurer requires and add smart convenience alongside it – for example a smart doorbell or a monitoring device that changes nothing on the door itself.
What to look for if you do buy one
- BSI Kitemark certification for smart locking devices. This is the big one: the lock and its app have been independently tested for physical security and cyber security, and are checked regularly afterwards.
- Secured by Design’s Secure Connected Device accreditation. The police-backed scheme for internet-connected products, introduced in 2022.
- A mechanical key override. So a flat battery or a glitch can never lock you out of your own house.
- Tamper alarms and two-factor authentication on the app.
- A brand you have heard of, with a track record of keeping its app updated. The lock is only as good as the software behind it.
- Smart home compatibility. If you already use Amazon Alexa, Google Home or Apple Home, check the lock works with your setup before you buy. Voice control and routines only work inside the same ecosystem.
Smart lock or a good traditional lock?
| Smart lock (certified model) | Quality traditional lock (BS3621 / TS007 3-star) | |
|---|---|---|
| Lost-key problem | Gone – codes and fobs instead | Keys can be lost or copied |
| Let people in remotely | Yes | No |
| Batteries and updates | Needs both | None |
| Insurance acceptance | Check your policy first; not all models qualify | Straightforward – this is what policies name |
| Physical security | Good models are strong; cheap ones are not | Independently attack-tested as standard |
| If it fails | Possible app or battery fault | Rare; a locksmith can open and replace it |
There is no universal right answer. A busy household that grants access to cleaners, dog walkers and teenagers gets real daily value from a certified smart lock. A household that just wants the door secure at night is often better served by a top-quality traditional lock that their insurer already recognises.
What AHLP can do
We will always tell you straight which route suits your door and your insurance. If you want a traditional, insurance-approved upgrade, that is what we fit every day: BS3621 mortice locks on wooden doors and TS007 3-star anti-snap cylinders on uPVC and composite doors – see our guide to anti-snap locks and which ratings to look for. If you are set on a smart lock, we will happily check your door, tell you whether it will suit one, and point you at the certification marks above before you spend anything. Photos of your door and lock sent to us first always get you the most accurate advice. All our prices are clearly on the website, we agree the quote before we attend, and we never start work until the price is agreed.
Frequently asked questions
Will a smart lock affect my home insurance?
It can. Many policies require locks meeting BS3621 or TS007 standards, and some smart locks do not qualify on their own. Check your policy wording or ask your insurer before fitting one. Keeping the rated lock your policy names and adding smart convenience around it is the safest route.
What happens if my smart lock battery dies?
Good models warn you for weeks beforehand, and most have an emergency option: a mechanical key override or external battery contacts. Choose a model with a key override and a dead battery is an inconvenience, not a lockout.
Can smart locks be hacked?
Cheap, uncertified models have failed security testing in the past. A lock certified with a BSI Kitemark for smart locking devices has been independently tested for cyber security as well as physical strength, which is why we say certification matters more than features.
Are smart locks suitable for uPVC doors?
Some are, some are not. uPVC and composite doors usually have multi-point locking, which needs a smart lock designed for it. Check the model against your exact door, and check the insurance position, before buying.
Should I get a smart lock or an anti-snap lock for my front door?
They do different jobs. An anti-snap cylinder protects against the most common forced-entry method on uPVC doors and is what insurers look for. A smart lock is about convenience and access control. For most homes the anti-snap upgrade comes first, with smart features added on top if they suit your lifestyle and your policy.
- Which? smart lock reviews and guidance, 2026
- BSI Kitemark scheme for smart locking devices, 2026
- Lock standards and home insurance guidance, 2026
Sources checked 25 October 2026. Policy requirements vary – your own policy wording is always the final word.
